LK-99, Part 2: What Independent Tests Found
Independent teams tested LK-99 after the July 2023 preprints. This timeline compares their synthesis, electrical measurements, and magnetic tests. The question is whether the reported superconductivity was reproduced independently. A calculation, a moving sample, and an electrical measurement each answer a different part of that question. The comparison below makes those distinctions explicit before the detailed timeline. What the Different Tests Actually Established Record Observation or claim What it establishes—and its limit Original LK-99 preprint, July 22, 2023 The authors claimed ambient-pressure superconductivity above 400 K . [1][2] Records the research team’s claim. Independent confirmation must come from other measurements. Sinéad M. Griffin’s calculation, July 31, 2023 Density functional theory identified isolated flat bands in a modeled copper-substituted structure. [4] A prediction about electronic structure, not a measured zero-resistance transition. Shilin Zhu and co...